NOOOO! Don’t Paint That!

We've all heard it "I can't believe you painted that piece!", aghast in horror at our willingness to cover such valuable treasures in a coat of paint. So how do I respond? Let's take apart this argument piece by piece.

A guide on how to answer the DON’T PAINT THAT FURNITURE crowd.

We’ve all heard it “I can’t believe you painted that piece!”, aghast in horror at our willingness to cover such valuable treasures in a coat of paint. So how do I respond? Let’s take apart this argument piece by piece.

* This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase I could make a commission at no charge to you. Please read my disclosure and my privacy policy here.

1. Its Not That Valuable After All

Most of the pieces I work on are in salvage condition, fair at best.

Antique value usually arises when the piece is in good ORIGINAL condition. If it requires refinishing, that implies this condition is not met. The bottom has fallen out of the antiques market, how many houses do you know that are full of rare antiques anymore?

A piece is only worth what someone is willing to pay for it, despite what that internet listing says. So chances are, if I bought it for $50, that’s all it was really worth.

This antique piece arrived in ROUGH shape

Don’t Miss Out!

Sign up to have all Brandy’s projects emailed to you.

Success! You're on the list.

2. Its Not An Antique

The definition of antique is 100+ years old. Those pieces are a rarity, and when they are found, they are showing their age, requiring a ton of work (see #1 👆).

Most of the pieces I work on are “vintage” at best (20+ years old).

Used a textured finish to camouflage condition issues on this piece

3. Painted Furniture Has Been Around Just As Long As Furniture Has

Go visit some of the great historic homes throughout the world, one consistency is… painted furniture.

Pigments were historically a luxury item, so having painted pieces was a sign of wealth and opulence. Some homes and furniture even used paint to imitate exotic species of wood, old faux finishes. That rare wood on your piece might be painted on!

The chalk painted looks we are now replicating are inspired by age-old homemade milk paint and chippy vintage finishes from pieces upcycled ages ago.

This was discarded on the curb for free!

4. If Paint Makes It A Show Piece Again, Then So Be It!

I’ve literally pulled pieces out of a barn, covered in dirt. Storage units, garages, even the sidewalk,  these pieces were being discarded and considered worthless.

If a coat of paint means a piece will go on display,  have a room designed around it, and be the pride of someone’s home again, then I’m all for painted finishes.

This one is a showpiece in my own home, something I enjoy every day

5. Know When To Hold-em

Have there been pieces that I acknowledge are better left unpainted? You better believe it!

Although few and far between. I usually offer these pieces for sale in their original finish for a time and hope they find a home before coming up to paint. They definitely take longer to sell.

The one that comes to mind was a set of Henredon dresser and desk that was in near flawless original condition. I oiled the vintage wood and crossed my fingers. It took forever,  I was on the verge of giving up, but a customer saw how gorgeous they were, while she was ordering painted furniture for her own bedroom by the way!

A nod to the past with peeks of vintage wood

6. Beauty Is In The Eye Of The Beholder

I have the utmost respect for well-made, quality, vintage furniture in all different styles, but for my own home, I choose pained pieces. I have very few wood finishes in my home, that’s just my personal taste, and I’m not alone.

There is a huge market for painted furniture pieces because people love it. I see them as functional art pieces in my home.

This piece looked perfect in its new home, full of color

7. Past Meets Present

I love to leave original details of pieces on display while updating them at the same time.

Wood-stained tops are one way to do this, by putting the old wood grain on display and contrast it against a newly painted body. Hardware is another way. I always choose vintage hardware over modern whenever I have the choice. Clean them, shine em up if needed,  and use that old hardware,  most are like jewelry made just for that piece

8. Mass Production

A lot of vintage furniture was mass-produced. The same pieces can be found over and over again. We all had that bedroom set from the Sears catalog, right??

Mass production usually means cost-cutting, plastic fronts, thin veneers, MDF drawer bottoms. Still great furniture, worth saving, but can be found a dime a dozen.

I’ve done this exact set twice now

If you like this Grungy Green finish, get all the details on how to recreate the look HERE!

9. Condition Is Everything

Some finishes are just not feasible on certain pieces. If the condition is poor, wood filler is used, repairs are done,  patches made… those can be very hard to hide with a wood stained finish. It’s not uncommon for paint to be needed to hide what’s underneath. It’s putting on your favorite outfit to hide the Spanx underneath.

Shop painting supplies and more of my favorite things in my Amazon Shop!

I pulled this one out of a barn, covered in dirt

10. Refinishing Is Refinishing

A coat of paint does not damage anything if the piece already needed refinishing.

If a restoration requires stripping, whether it’s just the clear coat or clear coat and paint over top, it’s the same process. Usually, the original finish is left intact, so anything over top could be stripped away too if in the future wood looks are all the rage again.

Stripping is stripping, think of it as an extra protective coat over top.

Took this one all the way back to raw wood with a bleached finish

Check out my Top Tips for Beginner Furniture Painters!

So, unless its quality of work we are talking, and that’s a grievance I do take to heart, because I pride myself of doing the job well, and poor quality paint finishes give us all a bad name, then the rest is just a matter of taste and I say “Paint Away!”

Don’t forget to subscribe for weekly Brushed by Brandy videos! I am working hard to bring you more fully edited video tutorials this year. And follow me on Facebook and Instagram to catch my furniture design projects in real-time!

This Post Has 12 Comments

  1. Tonya Johnson

    I love 💕 you Brandy and I am always enamored 🥰 with your art!! So paint on Sister!! You make those pieces beyond spectacular!!!

  2. Karen

    So incredibly well said! And informative. I did not know the part about painted pieces being a luxury item. Stay classy and sassy😉!

  3. Amanda Samways

    Dont let anyone tell you not to paint you are a recycler and in this day and age of waste you should be commended and of course you together with your hubby on vid, make these pieces come back to life,,, I just love your work and only wish I had a little bit of your amazing talent xxx

    1. Brandy K.

      Thank you!! I agree, no time for the haters

  4. Michelle

    Thank you for this, I’m so tired of hearing “Don’t paint that”.

  5. Kana


  6. Tricia Nicole Fletcher

    Hi, Brandy! I want to be you!!! 😉
    Can you share the soda blaster that you use? I LOVE Jacobean and recently purchased a table and chairs from the early 1900’s. There are about a zillion nails in each chair (they were fabric covered), and well, you know the details in the legs, etc. Thank You!

    1. Brandy K.

      My soda blasting gun is from harbor freight, connects to an air compressor

  7. Pauline Hunt

    Thank you for don’t paint that. I have a piece I actually hate. Frankly even I think it should not be painted, I am ignorant to its value. It was left in my mother-in-laws home when she passed. No it is NOT a family heirloom. My husband loves it as is. Trying to figure a way to live with it? My nightmare.
    That all being shared I never discuss what I am going to paint with the naysayers. We all know who they are. Loved your explanations. Made me feel vindicated. May have it printed framed and hung in my work area.

    1. Brandy K.

      I think you’ll love it even more!

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Brandy K.

From Trash to Treasure; using texture to save a sad furniture piece

From Trash to Treasure, saving a previously painted furniture piece using texture and color

Read More »
Brandy K.

Radioactive Vanity Re-do 💚

A vanity made over in blended blues and electric neons Catch the full video on my YouTube channel Here Materials list: Wise owl paint in

Read More »
Brandy K.

Black Friday & Cyber Monday 2021 Deals are here!

I hope everyone has a relaxing Thanksgiving, surrounded by family & friends, and all the blessings of the year! As we roll into black Friday,

Read More »